A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE SOCIO-LEGAL SITUATION OF DETAINEES BETWEEN TWO COUNTRIES

Authors

  • Judith Gayumba Martinez Ph.D. Prof Researcher in the Department of Law, at the Official University of Ruwenzori, BUTEMBO CITY, Democratic Republic of the Congo
  • LÉandre S. Thamuithe Ph.D. Student, Prof Researcher in the Department of Law, at the Official University of Ruwenzori, BUTEMBO CITY, Democratic Republic of the Congo

Keywords:

Crime, law, detained, prison, [conditions] prison, social, legal

Abstract

In the public and judicial administration, the management of penitentiaries is one of the major challenges of governments, an irreversible thermometer of respect for human rights in general and detainees and prisoners in particular. The prison standards in the social and legal conditions are not guaranteed to detainees and prisoners in some countries. However, in the organizational performance of jail and prisons, offering good living conditions to prisoners is a legitimate right. This research compares the detainees in Butembo/Africa with the detainees in Baguio/ Philippines. Through the comparative analysis in the quantitative approach, it reveals the extent of social and legal conditions of detention and survival of the detainees and prisoners inside the jail. In addition to direct observation, a questionnaire was provided to respondents. The results showed that the social and legal conditions of detention in Butembo and Baguio differed on the law, including 17% in Butembo / DRC against 80.6% in Baguio / Philippines. Both countries are varied, as to the social; Butembo illustrating mediocrity on reception facilities, food situation, health, sports and recreation, work, training and morale. Hence, there is a need of great deal and efforts in promoting the rights of the detainees and prisoners.  Meanwhile, in the Philippines, the rights of detainees and prisoners are at least kept to a minimum. It is a condition which Bumtembo/DRC in Congo and some other countries may carry out.

References

I. ACAT (2011), Humanisation des conditions de détention au Cameroun, Impératif d’adopter des peines alternatives à l’emprisonnement, rapport sur la situation des prisons au Cameroun.

II. BARROUE-BELOU R. (2014), Méthode et enjeux de la démarche comparative: la question de la comparabilité. www.droitconstitutionnel.org/congresNancy/comN4/barrueT4.pdf

III. CHALUS Aglaé (de) (2018), Au Brésil, la situation carcérale reste explosive, in La croix, Source : World Prison Brief, Département pénitentiaire national du Brésil et ministère de la justice français, mis en ligne le 4/1/ à 06h37, vendredi le 19 /4/2018 à 11h38 sur https://www.la-croix.com›Monde›

IV. DINDO S. (2014), Sortir de prison : le parcours d’obstacles, In Observatoire International des Prisons- Section Française, Paris, Puf, https://oip.org/analyse/sortir-de-prison-le-parcours-dobstacles

V. EVRARD T. (2009), On ne se reconstruit pas dans les cafards, La Libre Belgique, p. 3.

VI. FREUD S., « Quelques types de caractère dégagés par le travail psychanalytique » (1916), in L'inquiétante étrangeté et autres essais, Paris, Gallimard, 1985, pp. 134-171

VII. GÉRARD-SEGERS M-J (1995) Psychanalyse et criminalité in Le Bulletin Freudien n°25-26 Juin

VIII. Goaziou V. (Le) (2014), Sortir de prison sans y retourner, parcours de réinsertions réussies, Puf.

IX. JALUZOT B. (2018), Méthodologie du droit comparé: bilan et prospective. In Revue internationale de droit comparé. Vol. 57, on https://www.persee.fr/doc/ridc_0035-3337_2005_num_57_1_19332

X. MALICK BA (2010), Placement sous écrous et dignité de la personne, mémoire, inédit Université Gaston Berger de Saint-Louis, Dakar, https://www.memoireonline.com › ...

XI. NIZIYIMANA P.C. (2012), l’amélioration des conditions sanitaires dans les prisons du Burundi, Mémoire de Maîtrise, inédit, Université de Genève.

XII. ONUCD (2016), Recueil des règles et normes de l’Organisation des Nations Unies en matière de prévention du crime et de justice pénale, UN, New York.

XIII. PORTELI S. & CHANEL M. (2014) La vie après la peine, Grasset.

XIV. REJU E. (2005), La question, in La Croix, Paris, https://www.la-croix.com/.../LA-QUESTION-_NP_-2

XV. RENATO P (2012), Out of Prison, difficult reintegration, in Analysis: Vivre Ensemble Education, https://vivre-ensemble.be/SORTIE-DE-PRISON-Difficile.

Additional Files

Published

15-09-2018

How to Cite

Judith Gayumba Martinez, & LÉandre S. Thamuithe. (2018). A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE SOCIO-LEGAL SITUATION OF DETAINEES BETWEEN TWO COUNTRIES. International Education and Research Journal (IERJ), 4(9). Retrieved from http://ierj.in/journal/index.php/ierj/article/view/1648