INVESTIGATE TO ESTABLISH THE TRUTH – THE SOCRATIC METHOD IN MEDICINE

Dr. Leena Selvamary, Dr. M.B. Aswath Narayanan

Abstract


Socratic Method is a method of elenchus where teaching is done by a series of question which instills critical thinking and ultimately achieves illumination on the particular subject of debate. Socrates nurtured his students in a process of discovering truth and giving birth to new realization on their own. The PAPER CLIP method of Questioning by Douglas helps in framing the Socratic questions. Socrates method of educating a learner helps the learner to enlighten himself on particular subjects with clear understanding of concepts.

In the field of medicine Socratic Method of questioning not only helps teaching the medical learners regarding the facts but also brings out the cause of the disease from the patients during history recording helping in diagnosis. It also has its application in psychotherapy and in the process of counseling the individuals. In research the series of questions helps to test the generated hypothesis. And with surplus of evidences in the network and the current ease of access to technology, Socrates questions helps to choose the right evidence. Socrates method is often confused with simply posing a series of questions similar to pimping. This review highlights the detailed application of Socratic Method in the field of Medicine.

Keywords


Socratic, Socratic questioning, Socratic method, Socratic temperament, pimping

Full Text:

PDF

References


1. Investigation definition; http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/investigate, downloaded on 17.2.16

2. Scientific investigation, http://study.com/academy/lesson/ what-is-scientific-investigation-definition-steps-examples.html, downloaded on 17.2.16

Robert C. Oh and Brian V. Reamy. The Socratic Method and Pimping: Optimizing the Use of Stress and Fear in Instruction-Virtual Mentor.

American Medical Association Journal of Ethics.

, 16(3): 182-186.

Douglas R. Oylerr and Frank Romanelli. The Fact of Ignorance Revisiting the Socratic Method as a Tool for Teaching Critical Thinking. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education. 2014; 78 (7) Article 144.

Pezhman Zarhe and Jayakanna Mukundan. The Use of Socratic Method as a Teaching/Learning Tool to Develop Students’ Critical Thinking: a Review of Literature. Language in India. 2015; 15(6), 256-65

Allan S. Detsky, MD, PhD, The Art of Pimping, JAMA, 2009, 301, No. 13

Amanda Kost and Frederick M. Chen, Socrates Was Not a Pimp: Changing the Paradigm of Questioning in Medical Education, Acad Med. 2015; 90:20–24.

Wear D, Kokinova M, Keck-McNulty C, Aultman J. Pimping: perspectives of 4th year medical students. Teach Learn Med. 2005;17:184–191.

D.G.Grahame Smith, Clinical academic medicine: A Socratic dialogue, BMJ 1997, 315:593-595

J. Willis Hurst. The Over lecturing and Under teaching of Clinical Medicine, Arch Intern med. 2004; 164;1605,08

Robert C. Oh, The Socratic Method in Medicine - The Labor of Delivering Medical Truths, Fam Med 2005;37(8):537-9.)

Annette Burgess, Caroline Wright, Raf Qasabian, Deborah O Mara, Craig Mellis, Surgical teaching program for a senior medical students : room for improvement, Advances in medical education & practice, 2014,5: 369-375

Hugh A. Staddard and David V. O’Dell. Would Socrates Have Actually Used the Socratic Method

for Clinical Teaching?. J Gen Intern Med. 31(9):1092–6

Constantinou P., Daane S., Dev P., Transforming Information for Computer-Aided Instruction:

Using a Socratic Dialogue Method to Teach Gross Anatomy, AMIA,1043

Paraskevas, A and Wickens, E. (2003) Andragogy and the Socratic Method: The Adult Learner

Perspective, Vol 2, No 2,4-13

Jeanne Ting Chowning, Socratic seminars in sci

ence class: Providing a structured format to promote dialogue and understanding, Sci Teach. 2009, 76(7): 36–41.

Adib-Hafbaghery, Agajani.M, Traditional lectures, Socratic method and student lectures : which one do the students prefer, Webmed central/Research article,2011,1-3

Papanna KM, Kulkarni V, Tanvi D, Lakshmi V, Kriti L, B Unnikrishnan, Akash S, Tejesh S, Sumit

Kumar. S, Perceptions and preferences of medical students regarding teaching methods in a Medical College, Mangalore India, African Health Sciences 2013; 13(3): 808 – 813

Nadirs Pardo and Patrick Bakes, Application of QUEST model of questioning in the classroom Action research methodology in high school education, Journal of health science. 2015, 3:24-27

Tayyaba Ali1, Sina Aziz, Student's Perspective: Should Interactive or Non-Interactive Lectures be given to Medical and Dental Students?, ASH & KMDC 20(2):169;2015).

Rita Shah & Kyle C Kopko, Femiist Pedagogy and the Socratic method: Partners in the classroom or a disaster waiting to happen?, Higher education studies, 2016, 6(2): 39-49

Goldin AP, Pedroncini O, SigmanM. Producing or reproducing reasoning? Socratic dialog is very effective, but only for a few.

PLoS ONE, 2017; 12(3): e0173584.

James C. Overholser, Elements of the Socratic method: I. Systematic questioning, Psychotherapy, 1993, 30(1) 67-74

Jana Vyskocilova, Jan Prasko, Socratic dialogue and guided discovery in cognitive behavioral supervision, Act Nerv Super Rediviva 2012; 54(1): 35–45

Robert D. Friedberg, Where’s the Beef? Concrete elements when supervising Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy with youth, Journal of the American academy of child & adolescent psychiatry,2015, 54(7) 527-531

Braun, J.D., Strunk, D.R., Sasso, K.E., Cooper, A.A., Therapist use of Socratic Questioning predicts session-to-session symptom change in Cognitive Therapy for Depression, Behaviour Research and Therapy (2015), 05.004.

Gavin I. Clarke, Sarah J. Egan, The Socratic method in cognitive therapy A narrative review, Cog Ther res. 2015

Dieter Bimbacher, The Socratic method in teaching medical ethics, Potentials and limitations, Medicine, health care and philosophy, 1999,2:219-224

Ian Wylie, Sian Griffith, David J.Hunter, Everywhere and Nowhere-A Socratic dialogue on the new public health, BMJ, 1999, 319:839-840

T. Rick Whiteley. Using the socratic method and bloom’s taxonomy of the cognitive domain to enhance online discussion, critical thinking, and student learning, Developments in Business Simulation and Experiential Learning. 2006, 33:65-70

Christine Sorrell Dinkins, Finn Thorbjorn Hansen,

Socratic dialogue as a way toward wonder and aletheia in qualitative research and action research,

haser. Revista International de Filosofía Aplicada, 2016. 7,pp. 51-88

David Grahame-Smith, Evidence based medicine: Socratic dissent, BMJ, 1995, 310:1126-7


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Copyright © 2018 INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION AND RESEARCH JOURNAL